Jordan Watch
An update and analysis of the progress, or lack of it in political, economic, social and cultural reform in Jordan.

Jordan Elections: The destruction of political awareness myth in Amman

This is how the capital of Jordan, the city where the "supposidly aware" population, the intellectuals, professionals and economists vote declared its list of new deputees for the 15th parliament. This is how the myth of "political awareness in Amman" was destroyed once and for all. Remember that I carry the assumption that the government did not "systematically interfere" with the results which reflect the voters' choices.
 
In the first district the famous contarctor and self-proclaimed politician defendeing the rights of Palestinians Khalil Attiyeh managed to maintain his lead but with a reduced number of votes. This time it was only 14250 compared to 19000 in 2003. For a reason unknown to me and maybe to the majority of the population of this country the son of the other famous contactor Marwan Abdullat, whose name is Ja'far managed to collect 12000 votes in a district where very little Balqawis live in and where the Jordanian tribal lineage is linked to the D'ajah and Baraiseh clans. Moving from contarctors to the dealers of building materials the candidate Hassan Safi won the 3rd place. This guy was a simple dealer 5 years ago but then had a massive increase in wealth and prosperity from the construction boom. Now he is a legislator. Fedwa le3younak ya Urdon.
The head of the IAF block in the last Parliamnet, the solid and well articulate Azzam Huniedi barely managed to squeeze through. Biggest losers were the previous deputee contractor Abdul Haffez Al Heet, other iAF candidate Mousa Hantash and the ever losing rashed Al baraiseh. In fact all the D'ajah candidates failed.
 
In the second district Hamza Mansour scored a big victory supported by the radical IAF base. He was followed by Yousef Al Qarneh who is a local figure with good reputation and then the "double Kooz" winners coming from Al Wehdat camp. Biggest losers here were Musa Al Wahsh the second IAF candidate and Abdul Mun'em Abu Zanat the veteran radical independent Islamist.
 
In the 3rd district it has been proved that serving in the management of Amman Municipality is good for popularity. Mamdooh Abbadi (former mayor) and Abdul Raheem Bqa'i (former vice mayor) won. Ahmad saffadi also won and he is considered a candidate for the telecommunication companies. Fourth slot went to Yousef Bustanji who had a rather modest cmapaign focusing on constitutional rights that was less glamorous than Najati Shakhsheer but seemingly more convincing. Big loser here was Rehayyel Gharaibeh the second man in IAF and the leader of moderates. In the Christian seat, it was obvious that moving 6,000 voters from Al Wehdat will guarantee the win by the current president of Al Wehdat Football Club, especially when supported with vast money from selling food to the American army in Iraq. A support visit by Taher Al Masri was not bad also for the reputation.
 
In the 4th district the tribal balances were kept. Nidal Al Hadded won second place between Dr. Khalaf Raqqad and current deputee Hamad Abu Zaid. Clear and simple.
 
The fifth district wittnessed a strong tribal-financial competition. The first winner was Mohammad Abu Hdeib representing Balqawi lineage and based on his reputation as a previous good services deputee. Al Odwan tribe won the second place by Ahmad Yousef Odwan, a retired military officer. Biggest and surprise losers were two big tribes. Salah Louzi, the son of former deputee Mifleh Louzi lost as well as the Assaf family which was split between IAF's Nimr Assaf and another candidate. The Circassian/ Chechen seat went to Sameeh Bino former head of anti-corruption department at the GID and former minister and a strong figures with support from Chechen, Circassian and Arab communities.
 
The 6th district was a heavy fight of money. Nassar Al Qaisi was like a bulldozer with a very expensive and organized campaign. He spent a lot of money but with remarkable coordination. His ushers were in each and every voting center providing "guidance" and "advise" to voters as well as some refreshments and sandwiches. Countless buses and vehicles transferred voters to centers. I do not know much about him excpet that he is a dermatologist who owns a variety of companies (including a media and advertisement company) and got vey rich with recent land price boom at the airport road. Second wineer was a big surprise. Lutfi Derabani is a simple yet rich building materials dealer and managed to beat all the 8 Abbadi candidates losing the seat in their historic niche. The Circassian/ Chechen seat went to the wealthy, experienced and well-connected Munir Sober, a former minister and a previous senate who wanted this seat badly for the memory of his late father.
 
The 7th district wittnessed Al Ajarmeh tribe back in control after losing last time around. The winner Adnan Sawa3eer Ajarmeh is a young man and I ws honestly impressed with his tone and speech in a Nourmina interview. Maybe he can surprise a few of us.
 
Money, tribes, racial connections, contraction and new rich candidate and vote buying decided the fate of Amman elections. With a low turn out (about 50%) the capital of Jordan is no longer a place of "political awareness".


Bookmark this post: KhabberDel.ici.ousDiggRedditY! MyWebGoogle Bookmarks
(19) comments


Add a Comment

On November, 21, 2007 5:09 PM , ola
from Jordan said:

It was natural that all the 8 Abbadi candidates fail... the voters divided between 8 candidates at least so it was virtually impossible that they will win on clanish basis. However, Sayel Abbadi was running as the IAF candidate, but it seems it wasn't enough, it was one ferocious battle in the 6th precinct. I'm glad Lutfi Elderbany beat the odds because from what I heard he is a very good man and his campaign was clean and upright, no vote buyign involved.


On November, 21, 2007 7:52 PM , Sara said:

batir,,,whatever happened to your objectivity? how can you make such sweeping generalizations about Amman when the percentage of eligible voters who voted is less than 20% ? What happened in Amman is a de facto boycott of the elections.


On November, 21, 2007 8:57 PM , alurdunialhurr
from United States said:

معضم النصابين القدما قد خرجوا من هذه الانتخابات الغير نزيها بي مقاعدهم الازليه التي خصصت لهم من قبل الحكومه"الموقره" ..
هذه البرلمان المزيف سيكون مثل سابقاته ولن يجلب الي لشعب سوا المزيد من الفسادوالسرقات علي الوزن الثقيل،مره أخري الشعب الكادح سيكون الخسران من هذاالبرلمان الكركوزوالذي عتل علي كتاف الكثير من المضلالين الذين يعتقدون بي أن الانتخاب لهذا أو داك البرلمان سيغير شئ
أريد ن أسئل الحكومه،لماذالم تسمحو بموراقبين دوليين مثل الامم المتحده او لجنه من السوق الاروبيه المشتركه


On November, 21, 2007 9:42 PM , sam3aan said:

Why vote in an election rigged from the start.

"Staunchly conservative tribal areas are over-represented in parliament, with each MP representing 2,000-3,000 voters, compared with more than 90,000 voters per MP in the capital Amman."

http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/middle_east/7105281.stm


On November, 22, 2007 12:17 AM , batir
from Jordan said:

Dear all;
negativity can never be a valid approach. Every one who believes in democracy should get their asses up and organize themselves in political parties and movements. Nothing will happen with boycotting. People should be able to change the conditions of the political system and not remain negative and just criticise. If change will happen it will be done by people at the grassroot level. It will be done through democratic and representative parties. No execuse for the silent.


On November, 22, 2007 6:20 AM , masalha1
from Jordan said:

Sam3aan,
Yes the law has many flaws, the districting is unfair, but can we change any of that by having a bad attitude, and pout about it?? , or even worse sending incompetent people to run our lives??.
As long as we vote based on blood relation even though the person is worthless, we will never change a thing NOR if you set on your ass and do nothing.


On November, 22, 2007 7:21 AM , alurdunialhurr
from United States said:

Batir ,,off topic,I tried to log on Nassem's blog but it seems some body else took his domain name


On November, 22, 2007 10:03 AM , batir
from Jordan said:

Al Urduni I noticed that and I am trying to call him to clarify. Thanks for the concern.


On November, 22, 2007 11:28 AM , Eram said:

" Every one who believes in democracy should get their asses up and organize themselves in political parties and movements."

PLEEEEZEEE! stop pretending you live in Sweden or India. Jordan's dictatorship is protected by the US. It's hopeless. The decision to marginalize the silenced majority is approved and funded by the White House. The americans know if the silenced majority has its way, the US and zionist embassy in Jordan will shrink quickly. fact is, the loss of Arab freedom and dignity, either to despotism or to starvation and war is beneficial to US interests in the region.

why don't you start a movement Batir. put your money where your blog is. lead a civil rights movement to end US-sponsored repression and discrimination in Jordan. go for it and lets see how far you can go before your are dragged into the GID for a friendly interview. Abu Odeh tried to speak up against the marginalization of the silenced majority. he was silenced quickly. you were one of those who attacked him. so stop being a hypocrite.


On November, 22, 2007 11:41 AM , batir
from Jordan said:

Eram I will certainly be looking for participating in a political party but I cannot find any of the current serious enough. I will do my best to engage with the hundreds of people I know with reform potentials with the presence of experienced politicians to form this party/movement.
We do not have to be Sweden to form a party. Bangladesh and Mauritania are doing this in a productive way.
You are entitled to remain in your pathetic conspiracy theory state of mind but please do not spread the virus to others.


On November, 22, 2007 11:43 AM , bambam said:

lol batir i never assumed you will so wishful thinking, although i do agree with the sentiment but how do you exactly propose for grassroots to prosper if they are not allowed to congregate by law ? and report their dealings under the scrutinizing eye of law enforcement ?
the law to be changed by the people who managed to make it their in the first place based on the lack of proper representation ?


On November, 22, 2007 11:59 AM , Eram said:

Batir: "You are entitled to remain in your pathetic conspiracy theory state"

more of the "shallo man's" arguments.

Do you think the US invasion and mass slaughter of Arabs in Iraq is conspiracy theory?

do you think the starvation of Arabs in Gaza is a conspiracy theory?

do you think the US-backed Ethiopian invasion of Somalia is a conspiracy theory?

do you think the killing fields of Lebanon were US and Zionist conspiracy theory?

do you think the daily killing of arabs in Palestine and the third-class citizenship of Arabs in Israel a US and Israeli conspiracy theory?

do you think the erosion of arab human rights in arab countries during the cold war ear (communist purges) and post 911 (islamist purges) are conspiracy theory?

I just love neoliberals.


On November, 22, 2007 12:34 PM , bambam said:

grrr.... neoliberals again
how about thinking of it this way, they don't really give a flying ... about arabs and they shouldn't
leave the arabs on their own and they'll will manage to do your work for you while ppl like you wear their grim and morbid faces and bitch about no one doing anything and no one seeing the "truth"


On November, 22, 2007 12:57 PM , Eram said:

bambam. people know the truth. some benefit from it (regime parasites) others suffer from it (99% of arabs)

and no, you can't change it. you can't do anything about it, until oil runs out and israel runs out, or some outside force comes to the rescue, as in the past. fact is, arab elite are too corrupt and too self-interested to make a difference. history proves it. the savior is never arab, not since salah eddin and the turks. fact is, the contemporary arab elites are arguably the most corrupt generation of arabs that ever come to exist.here we are 20+ arab entities and counting, all impotent, waring, dysfunctional, repressive, regressive, traitorous, taking orders from states who pose existential threat to arabs. all making justifications and rationalizations for the status quo, simply because they are getting paid in cash. i refer to Nahid Hattar's article which Batir was kind enough to post, but what's shocking is that he, Batir, thinks he is better than those Nahid mentioned. Even more shocking than that is that Nahid Hattar thinks he is any better than those who criticized. it's hopeless when the reformer is corrupt but can't see it.


On November, 22, 2007 1:24 PM , batir
from Jordan said:

Eram, the political parties law states that 500 people from 5 governorates should be able to establish a political party and enjoy all thir constitutional righrs. Now, if I come to the conclusion after a few months that there are no such 500 people who are genuine enough to go and establish this party (which will not have to fight Israel and colonialsim but work for constitutional and economic reform in Jordan) than I will certainly stop all this effort which will be meaningless. At least I will have the satisfaction of trying, nonthelss. I can make a list now of 1000 people I know who share the agenda for reform, now how many of them will go to the step of signing their names on the application form remains to be seen.


On November, 22, 2007 1:45 PM , Faramel said:

people in jordan fear for their careers. they fear harassment. they fear isolation. they fear defamation by thugs. look at abu odeh and what happened to him. he was shut up pretty quickly. look at Ibn Irsheed and what happened to him. he was attacked by all sides, his very words mutilated. he did not stand a chance. you were part of the defemation and the attacks and the slander. but here you are playing Mr. Moderate, Mr. Believe In The System. man, you are such a hopeless hypocrite.

this is not a system that encourages peaceful dialog. you prove it. this is a coercive, repressive, closed system.


On November, 22, 2007 8:03 PM , batir
from Jordan said:

Yeh Abo Odeh is such a poor and marginalised man he only spent 30 years in the government and royal court. And how on Earth can you use the words "bani Irshaid" and reform in one sentence. Bani Irshaid wants this country to be fighting zone while we want prosperity and democracy. The two names you mentioned are completely out of the sphere of reform in this country.


On November, 23, 2007 7:38 AM , masalha1
from Jordan said:

Eram, Faramel,
Honestly, can Jordan afford to go against U.S wishes? lets be real, we tried that in 1990, we were suffocated by our own arab countries, our small and fragile economy went into a state of chaos, and half a million Jordanians were kicked back to Jordan, so what freedom are you talking about? the freedom to fight U.S against Jordan interest?? who will help Jordan if the U.S squeeeeeeze you to death? Saudi Arabia? Egypt? Iran?, So tell me what to do? OK Americans are killing arabs all over the world, and they all S.O.Bs does that change any facts on the ground? people wake up U.S is a super power and 5 million Jordanians mean nothing to them if you go against their interest so what can you do? set on a keyboard and tell me something most people know? do you know how much money in Aids and grants we get from the U.S ?? who is gonna replace that? Iran? Saudi? people stop thinking Jordan is china or Russia, this is reality take it and deal with OR Somalia and Sudan are a good example to what might happen if you don't.
Just focuss on your own problems, solve them, enhance your living conditions, then try to change the world, but first change your self.


On April, 26, 2008 10:06 AM , sswolfensteinss
from United States said:

Fyi: the world election watch dog rated jordan elections about as democratic as Saudi Arabias which means that is is not worth voting!When Are these Familiys going to give up power that they have mismanaged and humiliated the arabians with their stupid greedy ways and lack of knowlodge for the last 80 years ?When is the Arabian World going to have advanced arts and studys like Arabian people had when Europe was in the dark ages?Honest Rulers are needed in every Arab nation!These western imposed Traitors have made Gods blessed land a land of poverty and slavys !




Add a Comment

<<Home


Comments are not pre-approved. However, any comments including personal insults to the royal family members and insults based on Jordanian-Palestinian divisions will be deleted immediately. This is a platform for civilised dialogue, if you are not up to it go away.